Good for Manly - Candy Bingham
  • Home
  • About
    • Candy Bingham
    • Executive Committee
    • Good For Manly Association
  • Manly Talks
    • Previous Talks
  • Ferries
    • Ferry Facts
  • News
    • Manly Town Hall >
      • Town Hall Team
      • Town Hall News
  • Community
  • Contact/Subscribe
  • Become a Member

Picture

Beaches Tunnel Link EIS Released

24/12/2020

5 Comments

 
EIS (Environment Impact Study) for the Beaches Link Tunnel:  What does it mean for the Residents of Balgowlah?
The EIS was anticipated.  It is just that we did not expect the Government to dump it on us just before Christmas – and after the School P&Cs have closed and will not be functioning until the middle of February.  We know that TfNSW cannot hold proper community consultation sessions due to the Covid 19 Restrictions that we assume will be in place in January and February.

A copy of the EIS can be found at Beaches Link Tunnel and submissions need to  be lodged with TfNSW by the end of February 2021.

We have had a quick review of the EIS Documents (10,000 pages +) and would like to share with  you some initial comments on the documents.

While the Minister for Transport Andrew Constance made the point when announcing the release of the EIS along the lines of “this project will be built, some have thought that it could not be built, only the Liberals can be trusted to build infrastructure projects”, the final cabinet decision to proceed with the project has not been made.  There are several hurdles that need to be overcome:
  • The funding for the 3 inter-connected projects (Western Harbour Tunnel, Warringah Freeway Upgrade and the Beaches Link) has not been finalised,

  • The business case has not been submitted to the cabinet – and we know that the stand-along Beaches Link Tunnel Project does not have a good business case and will need a subsidy (hand-out) of around $5 billion,

  • Rob Stokes, the Minister for Planning and the State MP for Pittwater needs to sign off on the recommendations of his department after it has reviewed all the submissions to the EIS.
It is our intention to make a strong submission to the EIS – and to involve as many residents as possible in the process of writing and reviewing the Community Submission.

The project has been sold to residents of the Northern Beaches on the basis that it will allow a shorter commute to the City, the Airport and Western Sydney.  Never, has the Premier, or the Transport Minister or James Griffin told the residents that:  Once the Beaches Link Tunnel is completed, it will be easier for the residents of Western Sydney to drive to Manly, Freshwater, Curl Curl, Dee Why, Mona Vale and Newport than to drive to Bondi, Coogee or Cronulla.  Over weekends in the summer, there will be as many as 40,000 additional cars arriving in the Northern Beaches – and it is this weekend traffic that will boost the toll revenue for the owners of the Beaches Link Tunnel, the Western Harbour Tunnel, WestConnex and the toll roads leading into WestConnex.

In addition, here are some of the local issues we intend to include in the Community Submission from the Balgowlah Residents Group:
  • The traffic data used in the EIS is from 2016.  This is before the B-Line Bus became as popular as it currently is and before the announcement of the Dee Why to Chatswood Express Service due to start in early 2021,

  • In the entire EIS, there is only one reference to Covid-19 where TfNSW claims that there will be no no long term impact of the move to Work-from-Home on future traffic from Northern Beaches residents,

  • The impact local traffic in the vicinity of the entry/exit portals in Balgowlah and North Seaforth.  There is an acknowledgement in the EIS that “there could be an increase in local traffic along Wanganella Street North and South”, but this is an issue for the Council to deal with through “traffic management strategies”.  As vehicles will not be allowed to access the Access Road through the golf course site from Maretimo Street because of school drop-off in the mornings, there will be a major traffic pinch points at the intersections of :

  • White St and Wanganella St South:  This is because vehicles from  Balgowlah, Fairlight and Manly will be approaching Wanganella St along White St (close to St Cecilia’s Church) and will compete with vehicles from Balgowlah Heights, Clontarf and Seaforth who will be approaching Sydney Rd along Wanganella St South.

  • Wanganella St (North and South) and Sydney Rd:  Vehicles from North Balgowlah and Balgowlah will come along Wanganella St North and want to turn right into Sydney Rd in order to turn right into the Access Road at the junction with Maretemo St.  The vehicles coming up Wanganella St North will compete with vehicles approaching from Sydney Rd and vehicles coming down Wanganella St South. 

  • The intersection of the Access Road and Sydney Road (opposite Maretemo St):  Here, vehicles approaching along Sydney Rd from the Wanganella St intersection will compete with vehicles from Seaforth and North Balgowlah approaching from the Seaforth Roundabout.
    ​
  • The EIS contains no modelling of the traffic flows in Wanganella St and Sydney Rd.

Prepared By : Terry le Roux and Nerissa Levy
​Balgowlah Residents Group
Picture
5 Comments
Antony Hockly
5/1/2021 08:57:15 am

The whole concept of the road tunnel is flawed. The idea of the road tunnel would result in traffic chaos on the whole northern beaches area. A rail tunnel is a much more practical solution to congestion as well as being cheaper to construct it would remove many more vehicles from the already clogged roads and prepare the whole area for a much better transport system.

Reply
Patricia Lee
5/1/2021 09:23:07 am

I agree with everything Antony has written. Build more roads and more cars use them. A rail tunnel is the solution.

Reply
John D Wilson
5/1/2021 09:24:07 am

Sounds like the snob lobby and the car lobby want a subsidy and are jealous of the public transport sector which removes or at least reduces congestion while adding value to an area. The Eastern Suburbs are so valuable because they have such good public transport access. I think it is time to add to not reduce the quality of our public transport. Urgently bring on a rail line via Neutral Bay and Spit Junction to at least Mona Vale and of course retain and improve the big double ended ferries.

Reply
Stephen Coulter link
5/1/2021 11:33:08 am

I also agree that a road tunnel will promote more traffic an dnot reduce traffic - within 5 years - probably quicker - traffic will be worse. It is a well known outcome by transport planners globally - it is called "Induced Demand". A metro line can be built faster and significantly cheaper and transport more people per hour than a road tunnel. A metro could be extended as far as Warringah Mall or even Dee Why. It would interconnect to the Metro to Chatswood, the city, airport, parramatta and Sydney's NW. Cost per km is less than road tunnels as only one tunnel; is required.

Reply
Terry Ricketts
5/1/2021 04:03:47 pm

We can't justify this. It is going to negatively impact the northern beaches. Can it!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Candy Bingham, Manly Ward Councillor on Northern Beaches Council posts what's making news and issues relevant to Manly on this blog. 

    To subscribe click the RSS Feed button below

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    30kph Zone
    Amalgamation
    Art
    Balgowlah
    Bandicoots
    Bikes
    B Line
    B-Line
    Boarding Houses
    Boating
    Boat Trailer Street Parking
    Boy Charlton Pool
    Budget
    Candy Bingham
    Carparks
    Car Share
    Chid Care
    Cigarette Butts
    Clontarf
    Coal Seam Gas
    Community Services
    Container Deposit Scheme; Bottles
    Council
    Council Budget
    Crime
    Crows
    Cycling
    Development Applications
    Dogs
    East Esplanade
    Environment
    Fairlight
    Fairy Bower
    Footbridge
    Good For Manly
    Good For Many
    Graffiti
    Heritage
    History
    Hospital
    Infrastructure
    Jump Rock
    Kenneth Road Parking
    Lend Lease
    Library
    Lifeline
    Litter
    Little Collins Beach
    Little Manly
    Little Manly Point
    Little Manly Precinct
    LM Graham Reserve
    Manly
    Manly2015
    Manly 2015 Plan
    Manly Beach
    Manly Boy Charlton Swim Centre
    Manly Cinema
    Manly Community Centre
    Manly Council
    Manly Cove
    Manly Dam
    Manly Ferry
    Manly Golf Club
    Manly Harbour Pool
    Manly Hospital
    Manly Oval Car Park
    Manly Sea Life Sanctuary
    Manly Swim Centre
    Manly Vale
    Manly Village School
    Manly Wharf
    Manly Wine Food Festival
    Manly Women's Shelter
    Marine Education
    Market Place
    Miap
    Mike Baird
    Mslsc
    Norfolk Island Pines
    Northern Beaches
    Northern Beaches Council
    Northern Beaches Hospital
    North Head
    North Head Sewage Plant
    North Steyne Stormwater Pipe
    Nsw 2021 Plan
    Nth Beaches Council
    Oceanworld
    Office Of Information Commissioner
    Ombudsman's Report
    Parking
    Pedestrian Crossing
    Penguins
    Police Station
    Pollution
    Precinct
    Protest
    Public Transport
    Ravens
    Referendum
    Restaurants
    Royal Far West Site
    Rta
    Rubbish
    Safe Speed Zone
    Schools
    Seaforth Tafe
    Seagrass
    Sharks
    Shoroc
    Signs
    Speed Humps
    Spit
    Spring Cove
    Spring Cove Development
    Surf Carnival; NSW State Championships
    Surfing
    Sustainability
    Sydney Harbour
    Sydney Water
    Telstra
    The Corso
    Theft
    Toilets
    Traffic
    Trees
    Urinal
    Views
    Waste Collection
    Water Tank
    Whistler St Site
    Wi Fi

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • About
    • Candy Bingham
    • Executive Committee
    • Good For Manly Association
  • Manly Talks
    • Previous Talks
  • Ferries
    • Ferry Facts
  • News
    • Manly Town Hall >
      • Town Hall Team
      • Town Hall News
  • Community
  • Contact/Subscribe
  • Become a Member