A storm is brewing in Manly over the Northern Beaches Council’s proposal to cancel the Manly Resident Card which provides three hours free parking for residents in the Council’s CBD car parks. Former Manly Councillor and Good For Manly President, Candy Bingham, is campaigning against the move claiming it is unfair to Manly residents and that local businesses rely on locals, not just tourists, for their survival. “Manly CBD is our local shopping centre but the council car parks only provide two hours free parking not 3 hours like its competitors at Stocklands, Warringah Mall and all other shopping centres on the peninsula”, Candy Bingham explained. The introduction of an additional free hour parking for locals was a Good For Manly initiative which became the Manly Resident Card four years ago. The purpose was to support our local businesses as it was found that two hours free parking was not adequate nor competitive. For example we have a large number of hair, nail & beauty salons in Manly. It can take 2.5 hours to get your hair done which means that locals need to pay for the third hour parking, which costs $12.50. An expensive haircut! “We have large communities of swimmers who like to stay for coffee and breakfast; volunteers at the Library and Community Centre; friends meeting for shopping and lunch, all of which require more than two hours”, Mrs Bingham said. The Chamber of Commerce has come out in support of retaining the third hour free for locals saying their business is vital to the viability of most retailers in Manly. The Northern Beaches Council argues that the Manly Resident Card is not equitable, and is costing the Council $100,000 a year in lost revenue. However, this revenue estimate is challenged by parking expert and former CEO of Wilson Parking, Craig Smith, who says that research shows that locals resent paying for parking that they believe they are entitled to. “They would rather leave than pay $12.50 for an extra hour, or simply not come to Manly at all”, he said. “One way to make the Card more equitable and cost effective for the council would be to charge a nominal annual fee for the card, which can only be used once a day. Only one card is available per household. “The technology required to accept the card at the four Manly Car Parks is already in place and operating effectively. I hope the Council will review its decision and retain the Card albeit for an annual renewable fee”, Mrs Bingham said. Around 1,600 people obtained a Manly Resident Card from the former Manly Council, which then charged a one-off fee of $40.00. These cards are still valid for another six months only. A copy of Good For Manly's submission to Council to retain the card is below. Do you use a Manly Resident Parking Card?
16 Comments
Ann Smith
31/5/2017 07:11:10 am
I most definitely do use the card...probably once per week...do a class, have a coffee and do a bit of shopping...this usually takes just over the 2 hours free allowance. Am extremely disappointed at the prospect of losing the card. I will most definitely not pay for the parking and will shop at Stocklands or Warringah Mall. This proposal is extremely detrimental to Manly rate payers and business. Would be happy to pay an annual renewal fee.
Reply
Candy Bingham
7/6/2017 11:38:06 am
Thanks Ann. Your comments reflect exactly why GFM pushed for the card in the first place.
Reply
Elizabeth Maciver
31/5/2017 07:27:48 am
I park in the Whistler St carpark once a week for three hours at night in order to be able to go to a French conversation group in the library and have dinner afterwards with some of the group. I would try to park in the street if I had to pay for that extra hour's parking.
Reply
Barbara bevan
31/5/2017 07:52:33 am
I use my card a couple of times a week. I do a class and have coffee and shop. I have a massage, acapuncture and take friends to lunch. I cannot afford to pay for parking I will shop at Stockland or Woolworths Balgowlah where 3hours is availabl e. What a pity
Reply
Murray Sharp
31/5/2017 08:58:04 am
I use my card often and strongly object to it being removed. I do not object to residents of Warringah or Pittwater exclusively receiving concessions in their area. The benefits of the amalgamation are becoming increasing diminished in my view
Reply
Candy Bingham
7/6/2017 11:39:16 am
I agree Murray. Manly needs to be seen as a 'special case' in this instance.
Reply
Ursula Zuffo
31/5/2017 09:34:48 am
Our wonderful Manly restaurants, coffee shops and local business will suffer badly as loyal Manly residents will take their visits to Manly elsewhere.
Reply
Greg MITCHELL
31/5/2017 10:32:39 am
As an aging Manly Council ratepayer, I seldom need more than 2 hrs free Council parking in Manly, But when I do, e.g.,, to take the grandchildren to the beach, attend to some time consuming business, etc. 3 hrs should be available. After all as a Northern Beaches RATEPATER for 57 yrs, whose very limited contact with Council has almost universally been unsatisfactory -
Reply
Ann-Charlott Paduch
31/5/2017 11:44:33 am
Yes, I definitely use the card and find I usually stay in Manly longer than the 2 hours (supporting local businesses - yoga, cafes, shops). I agree with the comments made by Good for Manly that most people would rather roam the streets to find a park or not come at all than pay the expensive rate charged. So not much financial gain for the Council and potentially a big loss for local businesses if locals stop coming to Manly.
Reply
wing chan
31/5/2017 12:25:18 pm
I don't even know that a three card is available to residents in Manly at all.
Reply
DON WALKER
31/5/2017 03:04:36 pm
Surely the administrator is having us on. Why should Manly residents and business owners be penalised by removing 1 hour free parking to utilise facilities paid for by residents and commercial operators. There is one thing for sure, remove this 1 hour free parking and several other small businesses will be forced to close, one only has to see the devastation caused by the last council's idiotic decision to pedestrian Sydney Road in the CBD area. And why would anyone pay for this 1 hour parking fee when one only has to travel 10 minutes along Sydney Road to Stocklands and Warringah Shopping complexes.
Reply
Fran Gostelow
31/5/2017 09:47:44 pm
I purchased the Manly Resident Parking Card & thought it was a "one off fee" for the card. Very disappointed that this is not so. I enjoyed the fact that I had extra time in Manly to go about whatever I wanted to do.
Reply
Rose, Manly
4/6/2017 09:08:47 am
This is outrageous. I challenge the fact that the card is costing $100,000 a year in lost revenue. That's difficult to believe when 'around 1600' people have the card.
Reply
Candy Bingham
7/6/2017 11:40:54 am
Our parking expert, Craig Smith, also challenges the loss of $100,000. I think comments on this blog are typical. People won't pay for the extra hour - or simply won't come to Manly.
Reply
Jennifer Douglas
5/6/2017 10:20:51 am
I always shop at Stocklands and Warringah Mall as the limited time in Manly doesn't allow for a walk, shopping and a leasurely lunch
Reply
Jan Tagg
29/7/2017 09:20:25 pm
I also use the card several times a week and am dismayed that it may be discontinued. I take elderly friends to the hairdresser, Doctor, chemist, supermarket and enjoy lunch or coffee in Manly. I am often over two hours.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorCandy Bingham, Deputy Mayor & Manly Ward Councillor on Northern Beaches Council. Background in marketing, public relations and community engagement. Author of five business books. Former Lady Mayoress of Sydney. Aka Candy Tymson. Categories
All
........................................
View Videos
|